SAFFIRE-II
PSI-99PreventionSpacecraft Fire Experiment-II
Objectives
- determine how rapidly a large scale fire grows in low-gravity
- investigate the low-g flammability limits compared to those obtained in NASA’s normal gravity material flammability screening test
The Saffire-II experiment was performed on the Orbital Science’s Cygnus resupply vehicle after it deberthed from the ISS. As a follow on to the Saffire-I investigation, the Saffire-II investigation added more samples including SIBAL, silicone, structure PMMA, flat PMMA, and PMMA with Nomex. The Saffire-1I flight unit had a sample card installed in the middle of a large flow duct. Air is drawn through the flow duct by fans located at the top of the duct with flow straighteners at the bottom of the experiment module. Saffire-II has a sample card that contains 9 samples, each 5 cm x 29 cm. Depending on the sample material, the Saffire-II was conducted at an air flow velocity of either 20 or 30 cm/s, the flow being either concurrent or opposed. Once the sample was ignited flame images were captured using two cameras. In addition, thermocouples provided flow, flame, and plume temperatures, two radiometers recorded flame radiation, solid state sensors were used to measure pressure, CO2 and O2 mole faction, and two anemometer tracked flow velocity. All data was compressed, and subsequently downlinked. Details related to samples and experimental parameters are provided in the Experimental Details file in the Science document folder.
Conditions
| Parameter | Tested value or range | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Oxygen | 21.5 to 22.1 | % by volume |
| Pressure | – | psi |
| Pressure | – | kPa |
| Airflow | 20 | cm/s |
| Gravity | Microgravity | |
| Diluents | – | |
| Fuel phase | Solid | |
| Fuels | SIBAL, silicone, structure PMMA, flat PMMA, PMMA with Nomex | |
| Sample geometry | – | |
| Sample size | 5 cm x 29 cm | as stated |
| Hardware | Other | |
| Platform | – | |
| Years | 2016-2017 |
A dash means the sources do not state the value.
Variables varied
- air flow velocity
- flow direction
- sample material
Variables held fixed
None recorded.
Sensors
- thermocouples
- radiometers
- solid state sensors
- anemometer
- cameras
Findings (5)
Ignition
On sample 2-7 the PMMA portion was completely consumed and the Nomex was not ignited.
Flame spread
Silicone samples 2-1 through 2-4 have an insignificant burn time and a microgravity burn length of about 0.
SIBAL sample 2-5 burned 29 cm in 145 s in concurrent flow, with a microgravity spread rate of 2.1 mm/s.
Sample 2-6 burned 29 cm in 115 s in concurrent flow, with a microgravity spread rate of 2.6 mm/s. The material cell in the table is empty.
Extinction
On PMMA samples 2-8 and 2-9 the flames remain anchored at the base of the sample, which has a regression rate of 0.01 to 0.04 mm/s.
Fire safety relevance
The Saffire-II experiment provides a new way to study a realistic fire on an exploration vehicle, which has not been possible in the past because the risks are too high. Instruments on an unmanned cargo vessel measure oxygen, carbon dioxide, heat, pressure and flame growth, and two video cameras provide views of the flame. Results determine microgravity flammability limits for several spacecraft materials, help to validate NASA’s material selection criteria, and how microgravity and limited oxygen affect flame size. The investigation is crucial for the safety of current and future space missions. Studying fire in small, sealed environments such as the Cygnus cargo supply vehicle benefits fire safety and prevention efforts on Earth, including inside mines, airplanes, or submarines.
Oxygen and airflow
Tests that state both oxygen and airflow. Ignited and extinguished marks are the outcomes the source records, so the change from one mark to the other is the limit those tests show.
- Not stated
Tests (15)
| Test | Sample | Fuel | Sample geometry | O2 (%) | Pressure (psi) | Airflow (cm/s) | Diluent | Outcome | Spread rate (mm/s) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSI-99-T1 | 2-1 | Silicone | 0.27 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 21.5 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Burn Time: Insignificant, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 0, ?-g Spread Length: n/a, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: Acceleratory, Camera 1: S1C1, Camera 2: S1C2, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T2 | 2-2 | Silicone | 0.61 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Burn Time: Insignificant, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 0, ?-g Spread Length: n/a, 1-g Burn Length: 7.6 cm, 1-g Spread Rate: 1.2 mm/s, Camera 1: n/a, Camera 2: S2C2, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T3 | 2-3 | Silicone | 1.03 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Burn Time: Insignificant, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 0, ?-g Spread Length: n/a, 1-g Burn Length: ~ 0, 1-g Spread Rate: n/a, Camera 1: null, Camera 2: S3C2, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T4 | 2-4 | Silicone | 037 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Burn Time: Insignificant, Flow Direction: Opposed, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 0, ?-g Spread Length: n/a, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: 0.6 mm/s, Camera 1: S4C1, Camera 2: S4C1, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T5 | 2-5 | Cotton-Fiberglass (SIBAL) | 037 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | 2.1 | Burn Time: 145 s, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: 29 cm, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: Acceleratory, Camera 1: S5C1, Camera 2: S5C2, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T6 | 2-6 | – | 037 mm, 29 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | 2.6 | Burn Time: 115 s, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: 29 cm, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: Acceleratory, Camera 1: S6C1, Camera 2: S56C2, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T7 | 2-7 | PMMA & Nomex | 0.85 and 0.37 mm, 5 and 24 cm, 5 cm | 22.1 | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Burn Time: 140 s, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: 5 cm & 0 (note 2), ?-g Spread Length: n/a (Nomex), 1-g Burn Length: ~ 0 (Nomex), 1-g Spread Rate: n/a (Nomex), Camera 1: S7C1, Camera 2: n/a, Ignition Power: 80 W, Ignition Time: 9.2 s |
| PSI-99-T8 | 2-8 | PMMA | See Fig. 5, 29 cm, 5 cm | – | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Percent O2: 22.1 to 22.0, Burn Time: 600 s, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 10 cm (note 3), ?-g Spread Length: Note 4, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: Acceleratory, Camera 1: S8C1, Camera 2: n/a, Ignition Power: 97 W, Ignition Time: 30 s |
| PSI-99-T9 | 2-9 | – | 1 cm, 29 cm, 5 cm | – | – | 20 | – | Not stated | – | Percent O2: 22.0 to 21.9, Burn Time: 900 s, Flow Direction: Concurrent, ?-g Burn Length: ~ 10 cm (note 4), ?-g Spread Length: Note 4, 1-g Burn Length: Complete, 1-g Spread Rate: Acceleratory, Camera 1: S9C1, Camera 2: n/a, Ignition Power: 97 W, Ignition Time: 30 s |
| PSI-99-T10 | F1C1/F1C2 | Pre-test flow visulation data for sample 2-1 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Pre-test flow visulation data for sample 2-1 |
| PSI-99-T11 | F2C1/F2C2 | Pre-test flow visulation data for sample 2-2 | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Pre-test flow visulation data for sample 2-2 |
| PSI-99-T12 | row 12 | – | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Note 1 Derived from measured CO2 production and referenced to initial O2 concentration reported by ISS. |
| PSI-99-T13 | row 13 | – | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Note 2 The PMMA portion was completely consumed but the Nomex was not ignited. |
| PSI-99-T14 | row 14 | – | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Note 3 This is the length of fuel with significant visible damage. |
| PSI-99-T15 | row 15 | – | – | – | – | – | – | Not stated | – | Note 4 The flames remain anchored at the base of the sample which has a very slow regression rate (0.01 to 0.04 mm/s) |